Creamy, spicy and delicious, Arby’s Horsey Sauce is a mayonnaise based condiment made famous at Arby’s restaurant. No need to ask for lots of packets to hoard, use my copycat recipe to have an endless supply of horsey sauce at home.

 

Homemade Arby’s Horsey sauce

I love a good sauce to add flavor to a sandwich, especially when it comes to a roast beef sandwich.

This homemade Arby’s horsey sauce is one of my favorites to make. It’s the perfect compliment to to many different sandwiches and more.

Along with their famous Arby’s sauce and Red Ranch sauce, this creamy horseradish sauce was made to compliment their popular roast beef sandwiches but I also like it with burgers, curly fries, and fried shrimp.

Arby’s Horsey sauce ingredients

Just four simple ingredients are needed to make this recipe. You might even already have them in your kitchen.

• Mayonnaise – Use your favorite brand. You can also substitute with low fat mayonnaise.
• Cream Style Horseradish – This can be found in the condiment aisle. I like using the cream style because it’s a little milder and makes the sauce creamier. You can substitute with 2 tablespoons of prepared horseradish. You will want to use a little less than the cream style because it has more punch.
• Sugar – Balances out the heat and salt. This recipe uses 1 teaspoon. If you prefer yours a little sweeter, add an extra teaspoon.
• Salt – Just a pinch of salt needed for flavor balance.

How to make copycat Arby’s Horsey sauce

This is a seriously easy recipe to whip together. All you need are the ingredients, a bowl and spoon.

1. Mix: Combine mayonnaise, creamy horseradish, sugar and salt in a bowl. Stir until fully combined.
2. Refrigerate: Cover and let this sauce sit in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes to let the flavors come together. The longer it sits, the better. If you are in a hurry it’s ok serve it immediately.

How to store leftover creamy horseradish sauce

This sauce can be stored covered in the refrigerator for up to 7 days.

Heather’s recipe tips

• The longer this creamy sauce sits, the more flavorful it becomes.
• One great thing about making this at home is that you can adjust the measurements. If you don’t want to have leftover sauce, you can reduce the ingredients by half. Like your sauce a little spicier, add a little extra horseradish.
• Arby’s horsey sauce is known to be super smooth and that’s why I like to use the creamy horseradish sauce. If you would prefer to use prepared horseradish, use 2 tablespoons or prepared horseradish to replace the cream and then pulse it in a blender or food processor to get the smooth texture.

Why is it called Horsey Sauce?

Horsey is short for horseradish. Horseradish is a 3000 year old plant that is known for it’s medicinal qualities and taste.

The term “horse” is believed to describe the size and coarseness of the plant and “radish” comes from the Latin word radix meaning root. There are so many interesting facts about horseradish, this is just a quick summarization.

Common questions

More easy sauce recipes

• Cocktail sauce – Another delicious sauce recipe that uses horseradish.
• Tartar sauce – Perfect condiment for seafood.
• Homemade duck sauce – A great dip for your egg rolls.
• Green pasta sauce – Beautiful and tasty sauce made with spinach.
• Taco sauce – Easy restaurant style taco sauce.
• Garlic butter sauce – Perfect to spoon over pasta, seafood, chicken and more.
• Teriyaki sauce – Making this sauce from scratch is simple.

You can watch the video below for step-by-step instructions. Be sure to check out my Youtube channel if you like watching the recipes be prepared.